My forecast is lower than is justified on the basis of public polling data alone.  It represents my sense of things, anecdotal input, and  my efforts to register and influence voters.  

I have yet to meet anyone in Sarah's hometown who intends to even rank her as their 2nd choice, though clearly lots of those people exist.

People know Sarah.  There's no amount of advertising or campaigning that is going to sway voters her way.  What can/might/will make a difference is if the other Republican in the race urges his voters to rank her 2nd.  Sarah's only other hope is if the other Republican withdraws, but Sarah has called him a member of the Old Boys' Club and taunted him by saying that he is not man enough to withdraw, so I don't see that happening!  Sarah's campaign seems to have no momentum.

The other Republican is running a very negative campaign.  Judging by campaign donations, Nick is not doing well and will not be able to do much.  He has no momentum.

Meanwhile, Mary Peltola is doing a great job.  She is running some excellent ads and is getting a lot of positive press.  She has a tremendous campaign balance thanks to scores of small donations from Alaskans.  The more people learn about her, the more they like her.  She is gaining momentum.

Files
ctsats
made a comment:

Back when I was serving as a UN peacekeeper and field commander in Africa, I had made a practical rule, largely inspired by people who were sitting comfortably in their offices several hundred kilometers away, and were trying to tell and convince me what was the situation in my area or responsibility; it went somewhat like this:

When you are in the field, you know better; do not allow remote agents to convince you otherwise.

It may (or may not) have some (remote) applicability here, as well...

I, for one, do hear you and do take into account your forecast (and rationale), solely on the basis of you being a local field agent ;)

Files
JMR2017
made a comment:

@Anneinak 

538 has Peltola beating Palin in most polls pretty well. So, I'm betting on Alaskans being on to Palin's self promoting screams and rejecting her.

Files
ctsats
made a comment:

Actually, 538 currently gives to Peltola the highest chance between the 4 candidates (49%) - go here https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2022-election-forecast/house/ and hover over Alaska in the "map"

Not sure why, at the same time, they give Republicans a 51% chance of winning: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2022-election-forecast/house/alaska/1/

Files
JMR2017
made a comment:

@ctsats

Strangely enough, while showing 51% in the chart for Republicanswinning the seat, the headline reads:

"Democrat Mary S. Peltola has the best chance in our simulations, winning 49 in 100 times."


Files
ctsats
made a comment:
Yeah, I guess it's because adding the winning times of the other 2, it comes up 51 in 100.
Files
JMR2017
made a comment:
That makes sense.
Files
Files
Tip: Mention someone by typing @username